Influence Without a Product: How Economists and Policy Researchers Frame an EB-2 NIW

Economists, policy analysts, and applied social scientists often do work that shapes national decisions without producing a product, a patent, or a user count. That makes their EB-2 NIW evidence look different. This guide explains how to define a concrete ende…

An engineer can point to a deployed system. A biomedical researcher can point to a clinical trial or a licensed compound. A founder can point to revenue and customers. An economist who spent four years building a model that a federal agency now uses to estimate the cost of a regulation often has nothing comparable to show. The model lives inside an agency workflow. The decision it informed is credited to the agency. The academic paper describing it has a modest citation count.

This is the central evidentiary challenge for economists, policy analysts, and applied social scientists preparing an EB-2 NIW petition. Their work often matters most where it is least visible: in briefing memos, regulatory impact analyses, statistical methods, testimony, and data infrastructure that other analysts rely on. The national interest waiver framework can accommodate this kind of work well, but only when the endeavor is defined precisely and the evidence traces influence carefully rather than asserting it.

This article explains how professionals in these fields can approach the three-part framework from Matter of Dhanasar, what evidence tends to show policy influence credibly, and which framing mistakes commonly weaken otherwise strong cases.

Important: This article is educational and does not provide legal advice. EB1 Mentor is not a law firm. USCIS policy guidance on national interest waivers may change, and each case depends on its own facts. Confirm current requirements with official USCIS guidance and consult a qualified immigration attorney about your situation.

The Framework in Brief

Under Matter of Dhanasar, USCIS may grant a national interest waiver of the job offer and labor certification requirements when the petitioner shows that:

  1. the proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance;
  2. the petitioner is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor; and
  3. on balance, it would benefit the United States to waive the job offer and labor certification requirements.

Before any of that, the petitioner must qualify for the EB-2 classification itself, as an advanced degree professional or a person of exceptional ability. Most economists and policy researchers qualify through an advanced degree, but the threshold still has to be documented. Our guide on why an EB-2 NIW petition still has to qualify for EB-2 first covers that step.

For economists and policy researchers, each prong raises a distinct question. The first asks whether the endeavor itself matters nationally. The second asks whether this particular person is positioned to move it forward. The third asks why the United States is better served by waiving the usual labor market test. The sections below take each in turn.

Prong One: Defining an Endeavor That Is Not Just a Job Title

The most common weakness in NIW petitions from this field is an endeavor that is described too broadly. Statements such as continuing my research in labor economics or contributing to evidence-based policy are not wrong, but they do not describe something an officer can evaluate. They describe a career.

A stronger endeavor names the problem, the method, and the channel through which the work reaches national decisions. For example:

  • Developing and maintaining methods for estimating the regional employment effects of federal infrastructure investment, for use by public agencies and researchers.
  • Building statistical tools that improve the accuracy of small-area poverty estimates used in allocating federal and state program funds.
  • Designing and evaluating experimental programs that test interventions to improve completion rates in workforce training programs.
  • Producing analysis of supply chain concentration risks in critical inputs, used by policymakers assessing economic security.

Each of these describes work that could matter well beyond one employer. Each also makes clear how the work reaches others.

Substantial merit

Substantial merit is often the easier part of prong one. Work in economics, public finance, health economics, labor markets, education policy, and similar areas usually has evident merit. The petition should still explain it in concrete terms rather than assume it.

National importance

National importance is where the argument needs care. Dhanasar emphasizes that the focus is on the potential prospective impact of the specific endeavor, not merely the importance of the field. Saying that inflation matters, or that health care costs are a national concern, does not establish the national importance of a particular endeavor. The petition needs to explain how this specific work has implications beyond a single organization, for example through use in national policy analysis, through methods adopted by other researchers or agencies, or through broader effects on a sector.

Our article on how infrastructure professionals frame local work as national importance explores a similar challenge in another field, and our piece on why great teaching is not the same as national importance shows how the same reasoning applies when impact is diffuse.

Weak endeavor description Stronger endeavor description Why the second works better
Research in health economics Developing cost-effectiveness models for chronic disease interventions that public and private payers use to evaluate coverage decisions Names the method, the users, and the decision channel
Policy analysis at a think tank Producing quantitative assessments of tax credit design that legislative staff and agencies use when evaluating proposals Shows how analysis reaches decision-makers
Work on labor market data Improving the measurement of gig and contract employment in national labor statistics methods Connects the work to national data infrastructure
Economic consulting Developing methods for assessing market concentration in digital platforms used in competition analysis Identifies a recognized national policy question and a method
Expert insight: A useful test for the endeavor is to ask who, outside your employer, would notice if your work stopped. If the honest answer is a specific set of agencies, analysts, or researchers who rely on your methods or data, you probably have the core of a national importance argument. If the answer is only your current team, the endeavor needs refining.

Prong Two: Proving You Are Well Positioned When Your Impact Is Indirect

The second prong examines the individual. Relevant factors can include education, skills, knowledge, a record of success in related efforts, a model or plan for future activities, progress toward the endeavor, and the interest of potential users, customers, investors, or other relevant entities. For policy researchers, the most persuasive evidence usually shows that others already rely on the work.

Evidence that tends to work in this field

  • Citations in policy documents. References to your work in government reports, regulatory analyses, legislative research products, or reports by international organizations can show that decision-makers use it. Collect the documents and highlight the relevant passages rather than only listing them.
  • Use of your methods or data. If an agency, research center, or other researchers have adopted your model, code, or dataset, documentation of that adoption is often stronger than citation counts.
  • Invited testimony or briefings. Testimony before legislative bodies, invited briefings to agencies, or participation in expert panels can show recognition of expertise, especially when supported by official records.
  • Peer-reviewed and working paper record. In economics, working papers can circulate widely and be cited extensively before formal publication. Present both, with context about the field's publication norms. Our article on where preprints, white papers, and technical reports fit discusses how unconventional publications can be framed.
  • Funding and contracts. Competitive grants or contracts to perform policy research can show that funders consider you well positioned.
  • Letters from users. Letters from analysts or officials who actually used your work, explaining what they did with it, carry more weight than general praise from collaborators.
  • Media coverage of your findings. Coverage in national outlets that explains your findings can support the argument, particularly when it shows your work entering public debate.

Our detailed guide to why being well positioned is not the same as being qualified explains how trajectory and progress matter for this prong.

Tracing influence without overstating it

Policy influence has many authors. A regulation, budget decision, or program change rarely rests on one analysis. Petitions that claim a researcher's work caused a policy outcome often invite skepticism. Petitions that show the work was used, cited, or relied on at specific points in a decision process are usually more credible.

Claim Risky phrasing Credible phrasing with evidence
Influence on regulation My research led to a new federal rule My cost estimates were cited in the regulatory impact analysis accompanying the rule (exhibit with highlighted passage)
Use by an agency The agency depends on my model The agency's published methodology describes using a model based on my published method (exhibit and letter from analyst)
Public impact My work changed national policy debate My findings were reported in several national outlets and cited in legislative research reports (exhibits)
Methodological impact My method is the standard in the field Independent researchers have applied my method in published studies on several topics (list with exhibits)
Warning: Do not attribute policy outcomes to your work unless documents support the connection. Officers are familiar with the many voices in policy processes, and overstatement can undermine credibility for the entire petition. Show use and reliance, then let the evidence speak.
A report and an academic paper with matching highlighted passages linked by a red string, showing traced policy influence

Prong Three: Why Waiving the Job Offer Makes Sense

The third prong asks whether, on balance, it would benefit the United States to waive the job offer and labor certification requirements. Dhanasar lists considerations such as whether it would be impractical for the petitioner to obtain a job offer or labor certification, whether the United States would still benefit even assuming qualified U.S. workers are available, and whether the national interest in the contributions is sufficiently urgent.

For policy researchers, several arguments can be relevant depending on the facts:

  • The work does not map neatly onto one employer. Many policy researchers work across universities, think tanks, agencies, and consultancies. The endeavor may continue across institutions, which makes a single-employer labor certification an awkward fit.
  • The benefit comes from the specific expertise. A researcher who developed a method that others now use is positioned to keep improving it in a way that is not easily substituted.
  • Timeliness. Some policy questions have windows of relevance. Where the facts support it, the petition can explain why continued work now matters.

The third prong deserves its own argument rather than a single sentence. Our article on why waiving the job offer requirement still needs its own argument explains how to build it.

Three Hypothetical Profiles

The following profiles are hypothetical composites for educational purposes. They do not describe real people and do not predict outcomes.

Profile one: the health economist at a research university

Dr. Sofia Lindqvist develops cost-effectiveness models for interventions in chronic kidney disease. Her published papers are moderately cited, but her models have been adapted by several health technology assessment groups and referenced in coverage discussions. Her initial draft described her endeavor as advancing health economics research.

The revised endeavor focused on developing and validating cost-effectiveness models for chronic kidney disease interventions that payers and public agencies use in coverage evaluation. Her evidence emphasized documented adoption: methodology sections of reports citing her model, letters from analysts who used it, and conference invitations from assessment bodies. Her citation count was presented with field context rather than as the centerpiece.

Profile two: the labor economist at a think tank

Kwame Mensah, who holds a doctorate in economics, studies measurement of nonstandard employment. His working papers have been cited in reports by national statistical bodies discussing measurement challenges, and he has been invited to brief agency staff. He has few peer-reviewed publications because his institution emphasizes policy reports.

His petition explained the norms of policy research institutions, presented his working papers and reports as the primary output, and documented their use through highlighted citations and briefing invitations. Letters came from agency analysts and independent academics who had used his measurement approach, not only from colleagues at his think tank.

Profile three: the development economist moving into the United States

Dr. Lucía Ortega spent several years evaluating cash transfer programs at an international organization and now plans to evaluate workforce programs in the United States. Her prior work is strong, but the challenge is connecting it to a forward-looking U.S. endeavor.

Her petition defined an endeavor centered on rigorous evaluation of U.S. workforce development programs, explained how her methods transfer, and included evidence of progress in the U.S. context: a research partnership agreement, a submitted grant proposal, and letters from program administrators interested in her evaluation design. Her international record supported prong two, while her plan and early progress connected it to the U.S. endeavor.

Common Framing Mistakes in Policy Research Petitions

Treating citation counts as the whole story

Economics citation patterns differ from those in the natural sciences, and much policy research is cited in places that academic databases do not track well. Citation counts can help, but they should be accompanied by evidence of use in policy and practice.

Describing the importance of the topic instead of the endeavor

Every petition in this field can say that its topic matters to the nation. The question is whether this specific endeavor has national implications. Keep returning to the work itself.

Relying on letters from close colleagues

Letters from co-authors and supervisors can explain contributions, but they are less persuasive as evidence of broader influence. Seek letters from people who encountered your work independently and used it.

Ignoring the forward-looking element

Dhanasar is prospective. A strong past record matters, but the petition must also explain what you will do next and how you are positioned to do it.

Leaning on STEM framing that does not fit

Some quantitative policy research may connect to STEM fields or critical technologies, but applicants should not force that framing. Our article on what STEM and critical technology considerations really add explains when that framing helps and when it does not.

Expert insight: In policy research, the strongest exhibits are often the least glamorous: a methodology appendix in an agency report that cites your paper, an email inviting you to brief analysts, a dataset download log, a slide from a government presentation that uses your chart. Collect them as they happen, because they are hard to reconstruct years later.

An Evidence-Building Checklist for Economists and Policy Researchers

  • Write a one-paragraph endeavor statement naming the problem, the method, and the channels through which your work reaches decision-makers.
  • Search government reports, legislative research products, and international organization reports for citations of your work, and save copies with highlighted passages.
  • Document any adoption of your models, code, or data by agencies or other researchers.
  • Keep records of testimony, briefings, expert panels, and advisory roles.
  • Organize your publication record to include working papers, policy reports, and peer-reviewed articles, with context on field norms.
  • Collect evidence of funding, contracts, or partnerships that support your future work.
  • Identify independent experts and users who can write specific letters about how they used your work.
  • Gather national media coverage that discusses your findings.
  • Prepare a forward-looking plan that describes your next projects and how you will carry them out.
  • Draft a third-prong argument tailored to your circumstances, not a generic statement.

How This Field Compares With Other NIW Profiles

It can help to see where economists and policy researchers sit relative to other common NIW applicants. Industry practitioners, for example, often show impact through deployed systems and adoption by users, as described in our article on how industry practitioners build an NIW case without a research record. Policy researchers usually have the opposite profile: a strong research record but indirect deployment. Both profiles can succeed, but they require different emphasis.

For some policy researchers with exceptionally strong records of recognition, an EB-1A petition may also be worth considering. That depends on whether the record shows sustained acclaim at the top of the field, which is a different standard. A careful profile evaluation can help clarify which path fits best.

An empty public hearing room with a witness table, microphone, and folder in late afternoon light

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an economist qualify for an EB-2 NIW without peer-reviewed publications?

It may be possible, depending on the overall record. Working papers, policy reports, testimony, and documented use of the work can all be relevant. The petition should explain field norms and show how the work is used.

Do citations in government reports count as evidence?

They can be very helpful. They show that decision-makers use the work. Provide copies of the reports with the relevant passages highlighted and explain their significance.

Is working at a think tank a problem for an NIW?

Not inherently. What matters is the endeavor and the evidence. Explain the institution's role, publication norms, and how its work reaches policymakers.

How specific should my endeavor be?

Specific enough that an officer can understand the problem, the method, and how the work reaches beyond your employer. Avoid describing only a field or a job title.

Can I claim that my research caused a policy change?

Only if the evidence supports it. In most cases, it is more credible to show that your work was cited, used, or relied on in a decision process.

Do letters from government officials help?

Letters from officials or analysts who used your work can be persuasive, especially when they describe specific uses. Check whether any institutional rules affect their ability to write letters.

Does my endeavor have to be in the public sector?

No. Policy-relevant work can be performed at universities, research organizations, private firms, or consultancies. The question is the national importance of the endeavor and your position to advance it.

What if my work is international?

International experience can support prong two. The petition should connect that experience to a proposed endeavor with national importance for the United States.

Does quantitative work qualify as STEM for NIW purposes?

Some quantitative work may relate to STEM fields, but the label alone does not establish national importance. Focus on the substance of the endeavor and check current USCIS guidance.

Should I consider EB-1A instead?

If your record shows sustained national or international acclaim, EB-1A may be worth evaluating. The standards are different, and some applicants file both. Professional guidance can help you decide.

Conclusion

Economists and policy researchers do work that often shapes national decisions while leaving few visible traces. That does not make an EB-2 NIW harder to support. It makes it different. The petition has to define an endeavor that is concrete and forward-looking, trace influence through documented use rather than claimed causation, and explain why the United States benefits from waiving the job offer requirement for this particular person.

When those elements are in place, the quiet evidence of policy research, citations in methodology sections, briefing invitations, adopted models, and letters from the analysts who used them, can tell a compelling story about national importance.

Every immigration case is unique, and professional guidance can help you build a stronger portfolio around the way your work actually creates value. If you are preparing an EB-2 NIW as an economist, policy analyst, or applied social scientist, you can contact EB1 Mentor or explore our EB-2 NIW portfolio services. EB1 Mentor is not a law firm and does not provide legal representation; for legal questions, consult a qualified immigration attorney.

References and Further Reading

National interest waiver guidance and adjudication practices can change. Verify current requirements with official USCIS guidance or qualified legal counsel.

 

Every immigration case is unique. If you are an economist, policy analyst, or applied social scientist preparing an EB-2 NIW, contact EB1 Mentor to discuss how professional guidance can help you build a stronger portfolio. EB1 Mentor is not a law firm and does not provide legal representation.

EB1 Mentor Editorial Team
Editorial Team · EB1 Mentor
Live support